Five Years: Historic Episode Scores
Back in August 2006 I introduced the ability for users to rate episodes on a scale of one through five. Since the site has no user accounts this was always done in a fairly rudimentary way based entirely on IP address. So while these scores are by no means definitive, they do still have some merit and I think are overall an interesting look at which episodes are popular with people who visit this site at the very least.For Five Years of Mantis-Eye I wanted to do something with these scores, and this is what I came up with. From the depths of the database I pulled historical score data for 2007 through the end of 2009. Each list is a snapshot of the top fifteen episodes at the end of that month including the score down to thousandths of a percent just so you can see how close some of them can be.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
January 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.662 with 272 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.603 with 209 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.487 with 191 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.486 with 385 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.425 with 228 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.425 with 160 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.414 with 157 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.400 with 255 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.360 with 242 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.356 with 160 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.355 with 155 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.189 with 148 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.183 with 257 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.177 with 266 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.081 with 136 votes
February 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.644 with 284 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.592 with 218 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.495 with 392 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.477 with 197 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.422 with 161 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.411 with 236 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.405 with 163 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.401 with 262 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.348 with 158 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.345 with 249 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.337 with 166 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.177 with 153 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.174 with 276 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.171 with 263 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.085 with 141 votes
March 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.652 with 293 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.595 with 227 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.499 with 399 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.462 with 208 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.415 with 164 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.411 with 246 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.410 with 266 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.404 with 166 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.368 with 163 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.351 with 251 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.349 with 169 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.179 with 285 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.177 with 265 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.166 with 157 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.070 with 143 votes
April 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.656 with 302 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.603 with 234 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.510 with 416 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.459 with 218 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.418 with 177 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.413 with 167 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.407 with 275 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.402 with 256 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.352 with 256 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.339 with 177 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.322 with 177 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.201 with 298 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.168 with 161 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.158 with 272 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.069 with 146 votes
May 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.653 with 308 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.602 with 236 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.520 with 429 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.476 with 227 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.411 with 280 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.410 with 183 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.402 with 261 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.382 with 170 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.351 with 259 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.348 with 181 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.309 with 181 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.217 with 309 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.178 with 163 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.162 with 278 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.074 with 149 votes
June 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.653 with 314 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.607 with 239 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.519 with 441 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.485 with 231 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.419 with 186 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.413 with 286 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.410 with 268 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.382 with 170 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.341 with 264 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.339 with 183 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.321 with 184 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.229 with 315 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.182 with 165 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.169 with 284 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.098 with 153 votes
July 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.629 with 326 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.611 with 244 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.526 with 451 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.492 with 234 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.432 with 192 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.409 with 269 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.400 with 295 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.386 with 171 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.348 with 267 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.342 with 184 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.332 with 187 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.234 with 321 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.187 with 166 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.171 with 287 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.110 with 155 votes
August 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.615 with 338 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.602 with 254 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.524 with 460 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.504 with 240 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.424 with 198 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.411 with 304 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.387 with 274 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.379 with 174 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.358 with 271 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.356 with 188 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.346 with 191 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.232 with 327 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.170 with 171 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.168 with 292 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.108 with 157 votes
September 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.620 with 342 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.606 with 256 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.527 with 463 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.506 with 241 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.427 with 199 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.417 with 307 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.389 with 275 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.379 with 174 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.358 with 271 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.356 with 188 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.346 with 191 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.232 with 327 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.170 with 171 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.167 with 294 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.108 with 157 votes
October 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.607 with 257 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.602 with 347 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.529 with 465 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.506 with 241 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.427 with 199 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.417 with 307 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.379 with 174 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.373 with 276 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.361 with 274 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.356 with 188 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.346 with 191 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.232 with 327 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.170 with 171 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.167 with 294 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.108 with 158 votes
November 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.609 with 353 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.609 with 258 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.533 with 469 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.508 with 242 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.427 with 199 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.421 with 311 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.379 with 177 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.373 with 276 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.361 with 274 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.349 with 192 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.340 with 191 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.232 with 327 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.174 with 172 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.167 with 294 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.108 with 158 votes
December 2007
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.613 with 359 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.610 with 259 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.534 with 470 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.508 with 242 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.427 with 199 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.423 with 312 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.379 with 177 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.373 with 276 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.352 with 193 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.348 with 276 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.340 with 191 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.232 with 327 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.174 with 172 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.167 with 294 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.108 with 158 votes
January 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.614 with 363 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.612 with 260 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.536 with 472 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.508 with 244 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.427 with 199 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.425 with 313 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.379 with 177 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.373 with 276 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.356 with 194 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.350 with 277 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.344 with 192 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.232 with 327 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.174 with 172 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.167 with 294 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.108 with 158 votes
February 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.621 with 369 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.615 with 262 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.535 with 475 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.510 with 247 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.431 with 202 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.429 with 317 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.379 with 177 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.372 with 277 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.359 with 195 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.345 with 194 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.342 with 281 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.233 with 330 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.174 with 172 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.167 with 294 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.119 with 160 votes
March 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.622 with 373 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.619 with 265 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.541 with 481 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.510 with 249 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.436 with 204 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.431 with 318 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.383 with 180 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.376 with 279 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.369 with 198 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.349 with 284 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.345 with 197 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.235 with 332 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.179 with 173 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.170 with 295 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.124 with 162 votes
April 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.621 with 377 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.619 with 265 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.542 with 483 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.510 with 249 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.434 with 205 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.433 with 319 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.390 with 182 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.379 with 280 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.372 with 199 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.353 with 286 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.345 with 197 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.240 with 334 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.179 with 173 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.172 with 296 votes
Past Tense
Score of 4.124 with 162 votes
May 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.607 with 382 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.602 with 269 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.544 with 487 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.512 with 250 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.440 with 207 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.438 with 322 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.397 with 184 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.383 with 282 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.375 with 200 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.358 with 288 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.352 with 199 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.246 with 337 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.183 with 175 votes
Fallen Arches
Score of 4.164 with 299 votes
Shadowman 9: In the Cradle of Destiny
Score of 4.143 with 14 votes
June 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.617 with 397 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.602 with 274 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.554 with 502 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.518 with 255 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.438 with 331 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.434 with 212 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.404 with 188 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.385 with 291 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.374 with 206 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.367 with 30 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.362 with 296 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.359 with 206 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.341 with 132 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.252 with 345 votes
Eeny, Meeny, Miney... Magic!
Score of 4.174 with 178 votes
July 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.614 with 409 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.608 with 278 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.548 with 518 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.521 with 261 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.444 with 216 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.442 with 337 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.399 with 143 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.389 with 211 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.384 with 190 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.378 with 296 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.364 with 302 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.328 with 171 votes
Are You There God, It's Me, Dean
Score of 4.322 with 211 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.315 with 149 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.255 with 349 votes
August 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.610 with 418 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.603 with 121 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.602 with 284 votes
ORB
Score of 4.586 with 140 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.552 with 529 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.526 with 268 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.462 with 143 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.443 with 343 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.431 with 223 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.399 with 168 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.388 with 196 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.385 with 213 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.368 with 302 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.366 with 306 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.307 with 163 votes
September 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.613 with 421 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.604 with 285 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.599 with 132 votes
ORB
Score of 4.573 with 150 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.553 with 530 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.524 with 269 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.473 with 146 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.445 with 344 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.436 with 225 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.396 with 169 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.394 with 216 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.386 with 197 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.368 with 307 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.368 with 302 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.307 with 163 votes
October 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.614 with 422 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.606 with 287 votes
ORB
Score of 4.583 with 156 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.557 with 537 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.556 with 135 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.526 with 270 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.450 with 149 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.439 with 346 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.438 with 226 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.396 with 217 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.394 with 170 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.386 with 197 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.369 with 309 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.362 with 304 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.311 with 164 votes
November 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.616 with 424 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.606 with 287 votes
ORB
Score of 4.590 with 161 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.554 with 139 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.550 with 540 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.528 with 271 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.457 with 151 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.439 with 346 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.438 with 226 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.399 with 218 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.390 with 172 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.386 with 197 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.369 with 309 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.361 with 305 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.315 with 165 votes
December 2008
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.614 with 425 votes
ORB
Score of 4.607 with 168 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.604 with 288 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.559 with 145 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.550 with 544 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.531 with 273 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.468 with 156 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.443 with 348 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.438 with 226 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.405 with 220 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.386 with 197 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.379 with 174 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.369 with 309 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.355 with 307 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.325 with 188 votes
January 2009
ORB
Score of 4.610 with 177 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.605 with 428 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.596 with 292 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.565 with 147 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.553 with 552 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.531 with 273 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.485 with 161 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.438 with 349 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.438 with 226 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.405 with 220 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.389 with 198 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.365 with 310 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.364 with 176 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.346 with 309 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.342 with 193 votes
February 2009
ORB
Score of 4.609 with 189 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.582 with 153 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.553 with 552 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.552 with 433 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.535 with 275 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.534 with 296 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.509 with 169 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.438 with 349 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.438 with 226 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.405 with 220 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.389 with 198 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.367 with 311 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.365 with 200 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.348 with 310 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.316 with 171 votes
March 2009
ORB
Score of 4.599 with 202 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.590 with 156 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.548 with 557 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.542 with 434 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.534 with 296 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.533 with 182 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.516 with 277 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.441 with 227 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.439 with 351 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.407 with 221 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.389 with 211 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.387 with 199 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.369 with 312 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.351 with 311 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.301 with 176 votes
April 2009
ORB
Score of 4.594 with 212 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.576 with 158 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.549 with 559 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.542 with 434 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.541 with 185 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.535 with 297 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.516 with 277 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.443 with 228 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.439 with 351 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.407 with 221 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.401 with 217 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.387 with 199 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.369 with 312 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.349 with 312 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.305 with 177 votes
May 2009
ORB
Score of 4.609 with 220 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.569 with 160 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.560 with 193 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.550 with 560 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.542 with 434 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.535 with 297 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.518 with 278 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.443 with 228 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.442 with 353 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.417 with 223 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.410 with 222 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.375 with 200 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.369 with 312 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.349 with 312 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.312 with 186 votes
June 2009
ORB
Score of 4.618 with 225 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.577 with 163 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.571 with 198 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.552 with 562 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.542 with 434 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.535 with 297 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.521 with 280 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.445 with 229 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.442 with 353 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.421 with 228 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.413 with 223 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.373 with 201 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.371 with 313 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.349 with 312 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.312 with 186 votes
July 2009
ORB
Score of 4.587 with 237 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.559 with 204 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.554 with 565 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.543 with 435 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.537 with 298 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.530 with 285 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.500 with 172 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.433 with 356 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.429 with 233 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.422 with 230 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.377 with 228 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.376 with 202 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.371 with 315 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.350 with 314 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.319 with 188 votes
August 2009
ORB
Score of 4.573 with 246 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.564 with 211 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.554 with 569 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.541 with 440 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.532 with 301 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.529 with 289 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.486 with 179 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.435 with 359 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.423 with 234 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.421 with 235 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.373 with 319 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.362 with 207 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.355 with 321 votes
Ghosts of the Sargasso
Score of 4.325 with 234 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.311 with 180 votes
September 2009
ORB
Score of 4.566 with 251 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.561 with 212 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.554 with 569 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.541 with 440 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.532 with 301 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.529 with 289 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.497 with 183 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.435 with 359 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.426 with 237 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.421 with 235 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.373 with 319 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.362 with 207 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.354 with 322 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.311 with 180 votes
Tears of a Sea Cow
Score of 4.304 with 194 votes
October 2009
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.564 with 227 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.555 with 587 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.543 with 446 votes
ORB
Score of 4.542 with 275 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.531 with 307 votes
Tag Sale -- You're It!
Score of 4.522 with 295 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.497 with 195 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.438 with 242 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.436 with 369 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.430 with 242 votes
Blood of the Father, Heart of Steel
Score of 4.390 with 231 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.380 with 326 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.371 with 213 votes
I Know Why the Caged Bird Kills
Score of 4.349 with 327 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.316 with 187 votes
November 2009
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.537 with 620 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.518 with 463 votes
ORB
Score of 4.505 with 317 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.488 with 322 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.484 with 250 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.476 with 275 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.468 with 205 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.442 with 382 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.429 with 252 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.391 with 335 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.383 with 222 votes
Blood of the Father, Heart of Steel
Score of 4.369 with 317 votes
The Revenge Society
Score of 4.364 with 176 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.348 with 417 votes
The Buddy System
Score of 4.339 with 195 votes
December 2009
Pinstripes & Poltergeists
Score of 4.723 with 166 votes
Victor. Echo. November.
Score of 4.523 with 646 votes
The Lepidopterists
Score of 4.476 with 273 votes
The Invisible Hand of Fate
Score of 4.454 with 304 votes
Powerless in the Face of Death
Score of 4.453 with 404 votes
The Trial of the Monarch
Score of 4.450 with 269 votes
The Better Man
Score of 4.445 with 173 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part II
Score of 4.423 with 482 votes
ORB
Score of 4.414 with 367 votes
Showdown at Cremation Creek, Part I
Score of 4.399 with 336 votes
Blood of the Father, Heart of Steel
Score of 4.398 with 344 votes
Twenty Years to Midnight
Score of 4.379 with 441 votes
Hate Floats
Score of 4.379 with 346 votes
Return to Spider-Skull Island
Score of 4.377 with 231 votes
The Family That Slays Together, Stays Together, Part I
Score of 4.374 with 222 votes
Jump to:
You can also use the little form above to jump directly to any month/year. Apologies if the thing breaks and refuses to move, just refresh the page if that happens.
Trying to vote on a comment, eh? You need an account to do that! You should totally get one! You'll get your own username and can participate in community stuff. It's awesome! Already have an account? Log in above!